Wednesday, November 22, 2006

Thoughts on Satori


Baso abruptly taking hold of Hyakujo's nose gave it a twist. Over come
with pain, Hyakujo cried aloud; 'Oh! Oh!'
"You say they have flown away," Baso said,
"but all the same they have been here from the very beginning."
This made Hyakujo's back wet with cold perspiration. He had satori.

A monk called Joshu (Chao-chou Tsung-shen, 778-897) to be instructed in Zen.
Said the master, "Have you had your breakfast or not?" "Yes master, I have answered the monk. "If so, have your dishes washed," was an immediate response, which it is said, at once opened the monk's mind to the truth of zen.

I am reading D.T. Suzuki again for the first time since uni where we tried to digest bite sized pieces of his seminal (I hate that word) work on Zen and Japanese culture. What I remember of the lectures and reading is very fragmented, space junk really.

From Basho; a frog jumping into a pond.

From Bushido texts; make up tips for Samurai and the quotable pop culture soundbites like "the mind of no mind". Kind of fun to read because it's all in one ear and out the other without leaving you with a headache. Eastern thought is good like that. Plenty of vacuous crap has been made in the West based on the Hagakure (excluding Ghostdog of course) and many Japanese have been bored rigid having conversations with Westerners on the topic. What really grabbed me was the section of the course on wabi-sabi (thank god for wikipedia). Before I came to Japan I met a guy called Satoru at some live music event, his name is derived from satori, and as is befitting someone with such a name he seemed to be a pretty enlightened guy. I had some long gushing conversation about wabi-sabi, now I cringe a little but I guess it is an occupational hazard of being a Japanese abroad. After all, surely it is a more interesting conversation than one I get to have about the number of sheep in New Zealand. Why yes, there are alot of sheep in New Zealand, what a fascinating conversation this is going to be.........
"Why did you come to Japan", is a bit of a perennial question too. I sometimes throw in the fact that I did one paper on Chinese and Japanese philosophy at university as some kind of answer. In contrast with the all the heavy glutinous German philosophy and that slippery tricksy post-modern French stuff the Japanese stuff was relaxing; the mind of no mind; pretty pottery etc.
Actually it is a bit of a misleading answer, mostly I just liked the teapots (and Haruki Murakami) and wanted to get out and see the world.
Now, years later, I still know very little about Buddhism and Japanese history, or for that matter kanji, manga or cutting edge modern Japanese music. I just know alot about the texture of daily life, of city life. I live here and Japan is not an object of study for me.
An object of interest and endless facination; yes.
An object of study; not so much.
Unfortunately my grasp of the language has suffered from this approach to life here. You do not pick up a language like Japanese just by being here; big myth. You have to study. What little I do know involved some systematic effort.

Any-the-how back to satori, I started on this rambling narrative (not that should imply something is going to happen......) intending to recreate the mindstate I get into when I am alone at my desk, surrounded by the purposeful action of others, while I have nothing workrelated to occupy myself with. Everyone is busy, busy, I am just wheeled out for special occassions. A whirl of teachers and students, the air filled with people speaking Japanese (which is quite easy to block out), and me in the middle of it all with nothing to do, usually consuming text in one form or another. I alternate between the newspaper, my book and the internet. When the staff room emptied out today I finnally got a pic of this:


It hardly represents purposeful action, but it does scream "hey I"m really busy and don't even bother trying to tell me to tidy my desk".
I am sure it is not good for my mental health to read the paper from cover to cover, especially when read in tandem with William Gibson or Henry Millar. Reading any of those things will put you in a "not work safe" mood. So today it was arts and letters daily on the net followed by the Zen book. I read an interview in the guardian with the author of Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance. I've never read that book, maybe one day when I am backpacking through Asia.......
So he is describing an experience which could be considered "hard enlightenment" or cracking up.

'I could not sleep and I could not stay awake,' he recalls. 'I just sat there cross-legged in the room for three days. All sorts of volitions started to go away. My wife started getting upset at me sitting there, got a little insulting. Pain disappeared, cigarettes burned down in my fingers ...'

It was like a monastic experience?

'Yes, but then a kind of chaos set in. Suddenly I realised that the person who had come this far was about to expire. I was terrified, and curious as to what was coming. I felt so sorry for this guy I was leaving behind. It was a separation. This is described in the psychiatric canon as catatonic schizophrenia. It is cited in the Zen Buddhist canon as hard enlightenment. I have never insisted on either - in fact I switch back and forth depending on who I am talking to.'

Midwestern American society of 1960 took the psychiatrist's view. Pirsig was treated at a mental institution, the first of many visits. Looking back, he suggests he was just a man outside his time. 'It was a contest, I believe, between these ideas I had and what I see as the cultural immune system. When somebody goes outside the cultural norms, the culture has to protect itself.'

That immune system left him with no job and no future in philosophy; his wife was mad at him, they had two small kids, he was 34 and in tears all day. Did he think of it at the time as a Zen experience?

'Not really. Though the meditation I have done since takes you to a similar place. If you stare at a wall from four in the morning till nine at night and you do that for a week, you are getting pretty close to nothingness. And you get a lot of opportunities for staring in an asylum.'


The first thought I had on reading this was, no wonder his wife was pissed off! I doubt that many woman with two small kids get to experience that kind of enlightenment. Maybe that makes me a bit of a Martha. But really, it did remind me of a woman I used to work with, her husband told her that her being pregnant would interfere with his spiritual development and that he needed to leave; or some such crap. He was a yoga teacher. Bastard.
The second thought was; if staring at the wall is an opportunity for spiritual development I am expecting satori any day now.


No comments: